Natasha Lyonne
In American Pie, she played Vicky’s friend, Jessica. Maybe you remember Finch wanted her to spread rumors of his escapades to help him get a prom date. Anyway, Natasha Lyonne has become a true star since her American Pie days. Oh also she starred in the teen movie, But I’m a Cheerleader. Since then, she’s undergone open heart surgery and landed a star role in the Netflix show, Orange is the New Black. Now, the world is celebrating her role as Nicky. She’s been dating comedian Fred Armisen since 2014.

Natasha Lyonne
Beth Behrs
Perhaps, you recall Beth Behrs’ role as Heidi, Rob’s love interest, in American Pie Presents: The Book of Love. Today, most people recognize Beth Behrs from her lead role on CBS’s 2 Broke Girls. In addition, she’s had appearances on shows like NCIS: Los Angeles and Castle. Also, Beth Behrs presented at the Academy of Country Music Awards in 2013. After dating Michael Gladis for six years, they got engaged. Also, they starred in the Funny or Die short, The Argument together. Beth Behrs founded SheHerdPower, which works with sexual assault victims, pairing them with horses to work with as therapy.

Beth Behrs